Saturday, January 28, 2017

"Frugality"

            I’m resuming my blog after an unplanned hiatus last week due to the flu.  During this month, we have been examining five key virtues, which are at the heart of a distinctive Christian lifestyle.  In previous weeks, I described virtues as the values that define who we are as persons. Virtues are the attributes of our inner character that others see reflected in our outer life of words and deeds.  Think of virtues as “habits of the heart.”  Virtues become habitual, so ingrained within us, that they guide and inform our actions even when we are not aware of their influence on our lives.  These five Christian virtues strengthen us as Christians to live ethically in a way that reflects Christ in what we say and do—and, this leads to a distinctly Christian lifestyle. 

Over the past weeks, we have explored the Christian virtues of hope, love, and justice. This Sunday, I will focus on the virtue of frugality; sometimes called “temperance.”  For many readers, my inclusion of frugality may appear to be an odd choice, to say the least.  Within our culture and context, we tend to view frugality very negatively as the senseless denial of helpful and enjoyable products and diversions.  Among its synonyms for “frugality,” the online Thesaurus.com lists negative terms, such as stingy, meager, niggardly, penny-pinching, scrimping, and tightwad.[i]

However, the virtue of “frugality” does not have to contain negative connotations. The literal dictionary definition of “fugal” means “economical in use or expenditure; prudently saving or sparing; not wasteful.”[ii]  So, the virtue of frugality refers to the habit of careful, restrained use of goods and other resources; refraining from extravagance or wastefulness.  The virtue of frugality also includes an attitude of valuing all available resources and products.  This is a positive virtue.

Contemporary American popular culture frequently views frugality negatively because it assumes that extravagant consumption is required for happiness.  This perspective understands happiness rather narrowly, in individual terms, as the consumption of goods and services. Therefore, to be happy requires constant consumption of goods and services.  Further, this worldview assumes that greater happiness may be obtained by increased consumption. 

Thus, the prevailing vision for the good life centers on obtaining and maintaining an affluent lifestyle of continual and increasing consumption. This vision of the good life is grounded in particular anthropological assumptions about what it means to be human.  In this view, the essential defining characteristics of who we are as persons become our consumption patterns.  To be human means fundamentally to consume.  Thus, our self-worth becomes defined in terms of what we own and what we consume.

Given this prevailing vision of the good life and what it means to be human, then obviously the virtue of frugality must be viewed with disdain.  In a consumer-oriented culture that understands consumption as the key to happiness, then practicing the virtue of frugality is tantamount to intentionally choosing unhappiness.  Why would anyone choose unhappiness?

            But, is consumption of more and more stuff really the key to happiness?  Probably not.  We know from the vast amount of research conducted by psychologists and other social scientists that consumption of goods and services is not an important factor in experiencing happiness.  Instead, contemporary research among thousands of persons suggests that these are the keys to lasting happiness in life:

1.      Ongoing personal growth
2.      Positive attitudes towards life and others
3.      Strong inter-personal relationships
4.      A bountiful gratitude for life’s gifts and blessings
5.      A strong sense of meaning and purpose in life
6.      An ability and commitment to serving others.
7.      An ability and opportunities for making the world a better place; that is, making a real difference in the world.[iii]

Of course, this delusion that consumption is the key to happiness is not endemic to our time and popular culture.  Throughout history, many people have believed that happiness comes from being wealthy and having the money to buy whatever we desire.  This is the case even in the Bible.  In our scripture reading for this Sunday, the writer observes, “those who want to be rich fall into temptation and are trapped by many senseless and harmful desires that plunge people into ruin and destruction” (1Timothy 6:9).  That is, those who place their trust in riches end up chasing after many senseless, or even harmful desires, which lead to unhappiness rather than happiness.

Perhaps the most misquoted verse in all of the scriptures follows verse 9 above.  1 Timothy 6:10 is frequently misquoted as saying that “the love of money is the root of all evil.”  Actually, the verse reads:  “For the love of money is a root of all kinds of evil, and in their eagerness to be rich some have wandered away from the faith and pierced themselves with many pains.”

This is the crux of the matter.  It is not that resources and possessions are inherently bad—or evil.  Instead, when we become deluded into trusting our wealth as the key to our happiness and security, then we turn away from God and begin trusting in ourselves and our wealth.  We replace God with temporal goods and services.  Later in chapter 6, the writer of 1 Timothy observes that instead of trusting in their possessions, the rich are to use their wealth “to do good, to be rich in good words, generous, and ready to share” (verse 18).

The virtue of frugality helps us to keep our wealth and possessions in proper perspective.  By properly valuing our possessions, while at the same time using them carefully, we develop the proper attitude towards consuming goods and services.  Rather than trusting our possessions as the key to our happiness and security, we see our possessions as resources for serving God and the world.  As it turns out, this is the key to happiness and a secure life in God.  Perhaps the best summary of the virtue of frugality comes from John Wesley, who once wrote:  “Earn all you can; save all you can; give all you can.”

If you live in the Lincoln, Nebraska area and do not have a place of worship, then I invite you to come and join us this Sunday, January 29th, at Christ United Methodist Church, as we reflect on the Christian virtue of frugality.  In the proclamation, I will conclude with some suggestions on how we can cultivate the virtue of frugality in our lives.  The church building is located at 4530 A Street.  Our classic worship services are at 8:30 and 11:00 on Sunday mornings. 

Everyone is welcome and accepted because God loves us all.



[i] Thesaurus.com, “frugal,” accessed online at http://www.thesaurus.com/browse/frugal?s=t, 25 January 2017.
[ii] Dictionary.com, “frugal,” accessed online at http://www.dictionary.com/browse/frugal, 25 January 2017.
[iii] Readers may remember my sermon series last winter on happiness.  For a further discussion of social research into the keys to true happiness, see my blog post, “The Keys to True Happiness,” posted on 22 January 2016.

No comments:

Post a Comment